news.volyx.in

Jev in 25 Lines of Python (nobodywho.ai)

691 points by bashbjorn · 18 days ago · 212 comments on HN

Article summary

The article presents a simplified implementation of Jev, a large language model, in 25 lines of Python code. It uses a pre-trained Llama model to classify a given email as legitimate, spam, or phishing. The implementation is local, fast, and does not require sending data to external services. The article is intended as a parody, highlighting the simplicity of the underlying technology.

Main themes

  • Jev implementation
  • LLM calibration
  • Marketing vs reality
  • Technical simplicity
  • Confidence score calculation
  • Logprob limitations

What commenters say

  • The implementation lacks latency and compute comparisons to the original Jev model.
  • Some commenters argue that Jev's marketing claims are exaggerated and its technology is not novel.
  • Others defend Jev, stating that its implementation is more complex and nuanced than the simplified version presented.
  • There is disagreement over the difficulty of achieving calibrated confidence scores in large language models.
  • Some commenters believe that the confidence score calculation is trivial, while others argue it is a complex task requiring careful post-training techniques.
  • The use of logprobs to quantify uncertainty in LLMs is questioned, with some arguing that it is not a reliable method.
  • The importance of calibration in deep learning models is emphasized, with some commenters noting that it is a challenging task, especially across domains.