news.volyx.in

AnkiDroid: Google Play no longer allowing Open Collective donation link (github.com)

924 points by hexa555 · 41 days ago · 281 comments on HN

Article summary

AnkiDroid, a free and open-source flashcard app for Android, has been rejected by Google Play due to its donation link to Open Collective, a US non-profit organization with 501(c)(6) tax-exempt status. Google's policy states that apps may not lead users to a payment method other than Google Play's billing system, except for tax-exempt donations. AnkiDroid's developers are seeking clarification on whether their donation link complies with Google's policy. The app will be removed from Google Play on September 11 if the issue is not resolved.

Main themes

  • Google Play policy
  • tax-exempt donations
  • Android openness
  • app distribution
  • monopoly and competition
  • payment processing
  • developer freedom
  • platform control

What commenters say

  • Google's policy on tax-exempt donations is unclear and inconsistent with their actions.
  • The distinction between tax-exempt organizations and tax-deductible donations is crucial in understanding the issue.
  • Google's control over Android app distribution is a form of monopoly that stifles competition and innovation.
  • The ability to install apps from outside the Google Play Store is essential for maintaining Android's openness.
  • Google's restrictions on app installation are a step towards a more closed and controlled ecosystem.
  • The current situation with Android is already bad in terms of openness and freedom, and it may get worse.
  • Google's actions may be motivated by a desire to increase revenue and control over the app ecosystem.
  • The issue highlights the need for clearer policies and more transparent communication from Google regarding app distribution and payment processing.