news.volyx.in

AI companies destroy physical books – let's scan rare books before it's too late (annas-archive.gl)

646 points by Cider9986 · 6 days ago · 917 comments on HN

Article summary

AI companies are buying and scanning large quantities of physical books, then destroying them, in order to train their models and prevent competitors from accessing the same information. This practice has raised concerns about the preservation of human knowledge and cultural heritage. The article calls for volunteers to scan and upload rare books to a digital library before they are lost forever. The goal is to make human knowledge accessible and prevent it from being monopolized by private corporations.

Main themes

  • AI and knowledge preservation
  • book destruction and cultural heritage
  • copyright law and corporate interests
  • preservation of human knowledge
  • digital libraries and accessibility
  • corporate responsibility and ethics

What commenters say

  • AI companies are destroying books to prevent competitors from accessing them, not just to comply with copyright law.
  • Public libraries also destroy books, but with more careful evaluation and intention to preserve rare ones.
  • The scale and intention of AI companies' book destruction are what make it problematic, not the act itself.
  • Destroying physical books after scanning them is necessary to comply with copyright law and avoid lawsuits.
  • AI companies' actions are driven by profit and a desire to monopolize knowledge, rather than a genuine interest in preserving human culture.
  • The destruction of physical books is not a significant loss, as most books being destroyed are not rare or valuable.
  • The practice of destroying physical books after scanning them is a form of cultural vandalism and a loss for humanity.