news.volyx.in

_for-sale DNS records (specification.website)

440 points by shaunpud · 19 days ago · 167 comments on HN

Article summary

The article discusses a new DNS record type, _for-sale, which allows domain owners to signal that their domain is available for purchase without taking the site down or parking it. This record is defined by RFC 10023 and can be used to advertise the availability of a domain to brokers and availability services. The record carries a mandatory version tag and at most one tag-value pair, and its presence does not obligate the domain owner to sell. The article also outlines the rules for implementing this record and common mistakes to avoid.

Main themes

  • DNS records
  • Domain sales
  • RFC 10023
  • Domain ownership
  • Internet standards
  • Domain squatting

What commenters say

  • The _for-sale DNS record is a useful tool for domain owners to signal their willingness to sell without compromising their website's functionality.
  • The use of TXT records for this purpose is seen as a misuse of the record type and may lead to abuse.
  • Domain owners who publicly offer their domain for sale may be at risk of losing it to trademark holders, even if they have a legitimate use for the domain.
  • The concept of domain squatting is still a topic of debate, with some arguing that it is a legitimate business practice and others seeing it as a form of trolling.
  • The _for-sale record does not provide a binding commitment to sell, and its presence is not a guarantee of a sale.
  • The use of this record may lead to a situation where domain owners are pressured to sell to the highest bidder, rather than being able to choose a buyer based on other criteria.
  • The article's author is seen as having a questionable reputation and motives, with some accusing them of promoting SEO-optimized content.
  • The discussion around domain sales and ownership highlights the complexities and nuances of internet governance and the need for clear standards and regulations.