news.volyx.in

I'm switching my phone from Android to Linux (runarcn.no)

481 points by speckx · 21 days ago · 528 comments on HN

Article summary

The author is switching from Android to Linux on their phone due to dissatisfaction with Google's handling of the Android Open Source Project. They have chosen to install SailfishOS on their Fairphone 4, despite some issues with outdated software and broken features. The author plans to document their experience and may eventually switch to a Jolla Phone 2. They will continue to use an old Android phone for certain tasks that are not supported on Linux.

Main themes

  • Linux on mobile devices
  • Android Open Source Project
  • Google's control over Android
  • Alternative mobile operating systems
  • Mobile device freedom and privacy

What commenters say

  • Some commenters suggest that postmarketOS is a viable alternative to Android, with some devices having good hardware support despite the lack of official OEM backing.
  • Others argue that the level of support for postmarketOS is not sufficient, relying on volunteer work and hacks rather than official support from device manufacturers.
  • The use of digital keys and proprietary apps is seen as a major drawback for some, who prefer physical keys and open-source solutions.
  • There are differing opinions on the usability and performance of Linux-based phones, with some finding them suitable for basic tasks and others experiencing significant issues.
  • Some commenters believe that Google's control over Android is a major problem and that the company should be forced to divest the operating system.
  • Others argue that it is possible to use Android without relying on Google's proprietary services, and that alternatives like GrapheneOS offer a more private and secure experience.