news.volyx.in

Your 'app' could have been a webpage (so I fixed it for you) (danq.me)

895 points by MrVandemar · 48 days ago · 550 comments on HN

Article summary

The author of the article was required to install an app to access travel arrangements, but instead, they reverse-engineered the app and created a webpage with the same functionality. The webpage is more accessible, printable, and doesn't track user data or display ads. The author argues that many apps could be replaced with webpages, which would be more convenient and user-friendly. The article sparked a discussion about the role of apps and webpages in modern technology.

Main themes

  • App vs Webpage
  • User Tracking
  • Data Privacy
  • Native Apps
  • Progressive Web Apps
  • Mobile Technology

What commenters say

  • Many apps are unnecessary and could be replaced with webpages, which would be more accessible and user-friendly.
  • The main reason companies prefer apps over webpages is to collect user data and display ads, which can be blocked on webpages.
  • Native apps have benefits over web apps, such as faster loading times, home screen access, and more platform APIs, which make them preferable for many users.
  • The preference for apps over webpages is driven by companies' desire to monetize user attention and data, rather than providing a better user experience.
  • Some commenters argue that the distinction between apps and webpages is not always clear-cut, and that some apps provide unique functionality that cannot be replicated on the web.
  • Others argue that the benefits of native apps, such as security and accessibility features, outweigh the potential drawbacks of data collection and ad display.
  • The use of apps and webpages is often driven by convenience and habit, rather than a careful consideration of the trade-offs between the two.
  • Some commenters suggest that the rise of progressive web apps (PWAs) could potentially bridge the gap between apps and webpages, offering a more user-friendly and accessible experience.