news.volyx.in

Why American ambulance rides are so expensive (davidoks.blog)

327 points by jyunwai · 2 days ago · 480 comments on HN

Article summary

The article discusses the high cost of ambulance rides in the US, citing the case of a man who was charged $12,873 for a 6-mile ambulance ride. The article argues that the problem is not due to greedy ambulance operators, but rather the way ambulance services are funded, with a focus on per-ride fees rather than a premium-based model. This system leads to surprise bills and high costs for patients. The article suggests that a more efficient way to fund ambulance services would be to pay for the option of rescue through a premium, collected from everyone the service stands ready to rescue.

Main themes

  • Ambulance costs
  • US healthcare system
  • Emergency medical services
  • Funding models
  • Surprise billing
  • Healthcare economics

What commenters say

  • The US healthcare system is flawed and prioritizes profits over people, leading to exorbitant ambulance costs.
  • The cost of ambulance rides is not due to greed, but rather the result of a complex and inefficient funding system.
  • A premium-based model, where everyone pays a small fee for ambulance services, could be a more efficient and equitable solution.
  • Some argue that the current system is necessary to maintain freedom of choice, while others see it as a failure of the system to prioritize people's needs.
  • The comparison to other countries with more comprehensive and affordable healthcare systems highlights the need for reform in the US.
  • The issue of ambulance costs is part of a broader problem of unequal access to healthcare and financial burden on individuals.
  • Some commenters suggest that the solution lies in making ambulance services more like fire and police departments, with funding through taxes or other public means.
  • Others argue that the current system is working as intended, and that those who cannot afford ambulance services are a minority who can be accommodated through other means.