news.volyx.in

98% isn't much (whynothugo.nl)

525 points by speckx · 4 days ago · 350 comments on HN

Article summary

The article argues that 98% is not a high enough success rate for certain aspects of life, such as a restaurant not giving customers food poisoning or a website working for all users. It highlights that 98% can be misleading, as it may not account for specific audiences or edge cases. The author emphasizes the importance of robust engineering and graceful degradation to ensure a good experience for all users. This concept is illustrated with examples of browser support and website design.

Main themes

  • Statistics and interpretation
  • Browser support and compatibility
  • User experience and accessibility
  • Edge cases and robust engineering
  • Business and revenue considerations

What commenters say

  • Supporting old browsers can be a significant burden and may hinder progress in web development.
  • Some users are locked into old devices or browsers due to various constraints, such as work or resource limitations, and should not be excluded.
  • The decision to support older browsers depends on the specific business or market, and the potential revenue generated by those users.
  • Forcing users to upgrade their browsers can be seen as a form of class discrimination, excluding those who cannot afford or access newer technology.
  • The importance of accessibility and user experience should take precedence over the desire to use the latest features or technologies.
  • In competitive markets, supporting older browsers may be necessary to maintain a significant user base and revenue stream.
  • There is a point at which supporting outdated browsers becomes unsustainable and hinders the development of new features and technologies.
  • The concept of 98% success rate can be misleading and ignores the importance of edge cases and robust engineering in ensuring a good user experience.