news.volyx.in

StreetComplete: Fixing OpenStreetMap, one tiny quest at a time (streetcomplete.app)

822 points by kls0e · 4 days ago · 206 comments on HN

Article summary

The article discusses StreetComplete, an app that allows users to contribute to OpenStreetMap by completing small tasks, such as labeling and adding missing data. The app is designed to be beginner-friendly and has a well-done UI. Users can contribute to the map by completing quests, which can be a fun and engaging way to improve the accuracy of the map. The app has various features, including the ability to add simple roads and footpaths, and has a companion app called StreetMeasure that uses Google's AR measuring capability.

Main themes

  • OpenStreetMap contributions
  • StreetComplete app
  • Mapping and geography
  • Data collection and usage
  • Mobile apps for mapping
  • Beginner-friendly mapping tools

What commenters say

  • StreetComplete is a fun and beginner-friendly way to contribute to OpenStreetMap, with a well-designed UI that makes it easy to get started.
  • The app has limitations, such as not allowing users to add simple roads and footpaths, but it is still a useful tool for contributing to the map.
  • Some users are concerned about the potential misuse of OpenStreetMap data by military or other organizations, but others argue that the data is open-source and publicly available.
  • The app's focus on small, discrete tasks makes it accessible to casual users, but may not be suitable for more complex mapping tasks that require a full-featured editor.
  • The comparison to Pokémon Go highlights the difference between open-source, public data collection and proprietary data collection for commercial gain.
  • Some users appreciate the ability to contribute to the map in a way that is transparent and controllable, unlike some commercial mapping apps.
  • The app's design intentionally hides some features, such as overlays, to retain beginner-friendliness, but these features can be useful for power users.
  • StreetComplete is not the only app available for contributing to OpenStreetMap, and some users prefer other apps, such as Vespucci or EveryDoor, for certain tasks.