news.volyx.in

FFmpeg 9.1's new AAC encoder (hydrogenaudio.org)

448 points by ledoge · 58 days ago · 151 comments on HN

Article summary

The article discusses the new AAC encoder in FFmpeg 9.1, but the link to the article is incorrect. The discussion revolves around audio encoding, sampling rates, and the quality of audio. The new AAC encoder is optimized for 48kHz audio, which is considered the standard for most applications. The encoder's performance and quality are debated in the comments.

Main themes

  • Audio encoding
  • Sampling rates
  • AAC encoder
  • Audio quality
  • FFmpeg 9.1
  • Audio production

What commenters say

  • The new AAC encoder in FFmpeg 9.1 is optimized for 48kHz audio, which is considered the standard for most applications.
  • Higher sampling rates, such as 96kHz, are not necessary for consumer applications and do not provide a noticeable difference in audio quality.
  • Some argue that higher sampling rates are useful for professional audio production and editing, but not for storage or playback.
  • The choice of sampling rate depends on the specific use case, with 48kHz being sufficient for most applications, but higher rates being necessary for certain professional or niche uses.
  • Lossless audio is not necessary for consumer applications, but can be useful for archival purposes, allowing for re-encoding with the latest lossy encoders.
  • The quality of audio is not solely determined by the sampling rate, but also by other factors such as the quality of the encoding algorithm and the playback equipment.
  • Some commenters disagree on the importance of higher sampling rates, with some arguing that they are necessary for certain applications, while others see no benefit.
  • The perception of audio quality is subjective and can vary greatly from person to person, making it difficult to determine the optimal sampling rate or encoding settings.