European digital ID wallets rely on safety services of Google and Apple (waag.org)

Article summary

European governments are rolling out digital identity wallets that rely on safety services from Google and Apple, which could lead to dependence on private companies and undermine digital sovereignty. The use of Google's Play Integrity API and Apple's Managed Device Attestation may exclude alternative operating systems and reinforce the dominance of these tech giants. This approach contradicts the EU's goals of promoting openness, inclusiveness, and technological sovereignty. The article argues that a more open alternative, such as Android's Hardware Attestation API, should be considered.

Main themes

• Digital sovereignty
• European digital ID wallets
• Google and Apple dominance
• Technological independence
• Privacy and security
• Regulatory challenges

What commenters say

• The reliance on Google and Apple's safety services undermines the EU's efforts to promote digital sovereignty and independence.
• Alternative operating systems, such as those based on Android, can provide a more open and secure solution for digital identity wallets.
• The use of Google's Play Integrity API and Apple's Managed Device Attestation may be necessary for security, but it also reinforces the dominance of these tech giants.
• European governments should prioritize the development of indigenous technologies and infrastructure to reduce dependence on US companies.
• The EU's regulatory framework is insufficient to address the challenges posed by the dominance of Google and Apple in the digital landscape.
• The adoption of digital identity wallets should be driven by user needs and preferences, rather than the interests of private companies.
• The CLOUD Act and other US laws pose a significant threat to European digital sovereignty and the privacy of EU citizens.
• A unified approach to digital identity wallets and regulatory frameworks is necessary to ensure consistency and effectiveness across the EU.