news.volyx.in

Why does kinetic energy increase quadratically, not linearly, with speed? (2011) (physics.stackexchange.com)

381 points by ProxyTracer · 63 days ago · 215 comments on HN

Article summary

The article discusses why kinetic energy increases quadratically with speed, rather than linearly. It explains that this can be understood through the concept of work and energy, and that the quadratic relationship is a fundamental aspect of physics. The article also provides an intuitive explanation for this phenomenon, using the example of a ball of clay smacking into a wall. This explanation is based on the idea that the kinetic energy of an object is proportional to the square of its velocity.

Main themes

  • Kinetic Energy
  • Work and Energy
  • Physics Fundamentals
  • Intuitive Explanations
  • Mathematical Derivations

What commenters say

  • The quadratic relationship between kinetic energy and speed can be understood through the concept of work and energy, and is a fundamental aspect of physics.
  • The explanation for the quadratic relationship can be approached through intuitive examples, such as the braking distance of cars, to illustrate the concept.
  • Some commenters argue that the quadratic relationship is not immediately obvious and requires a deeper understanding of physics and mathematics to fully comprehend.
  • Others suggest that the use of analogies, such as the braking distance of cars, can help to make the concept more accessible and intuitive.
  • There is disagreement among commenters about the best way to approach teaching and learning physics, with some arguing that it should be taught in a more historical and contextual manner.
  • Some commenters express frustration with the way physics is often taught, feeling that it is presented as a set of axiomatic rules rather than a dynamic and evolving field of study.
  • The discussion highlights the importance of considering multiple perspectives and approaches to understanding complex concepts in physics.
  • The use of real-world examples and analogies can be an effective way to illustrate complex physics concepts and make them more accessible to a wider audience.