news.volyx.in

How to get better at guitar (jakeworth.com)

473 points by jwworth · 148 days ago · 263 comments on HN

Article summary

The article discusses a method for learning guitar by listening to and transcribing songs, rather than relying on tablature. This approach involves stopping and starting a song to identify and write down individual notes, and then comparing the transcription to others to refine it. The author finds this method to be effective for improving their guitar playing skills. By learning songs in this way, guitarists can develop their ability to hear and play music, rather than just reading tabs.

Main themes

  • guitar learning methods
  • practice and technique
  • music theory and ear training
  • effective practice habits
  • tool use and distraction
  • learning and improvement strategies

What commenters say

  • Effective practice is key to improving guitar skills, regardless of the method used.
  • Some argue that traditional music theory and technique are not necessary for skilled playing, as long as practice and determination are present.
  • Others believe that proper technique is essential for efficient and effective playing, and that bad habits can hinder progress.
  • The importance of ear training and transcription in learning music is emphasized by some commenters.
  • Frequency and consistency of practice are considered more important than duration by some, while others prioritize focused practice on specific skills or songs.
  • There is disagreement on whether certain techniques or methods are more effective than others for learning guitar, with some advocating for a more intuitive or ear-based approach.
  • Some commenters note that learning music theory, such as pentatonic scales, can be a significant step forward in improving guitar skills.
  • The use of tools or technology, such as apps or software, can be a distraction from the actual task of practicing and learning music.