news.volyx.in

Tell HN: Anthropic no longer allowing Claude Code subscriptions to use OpenClaw

1099 points by firloop · 149 days ago · 827 comments on HN

Article summary

Anthropic is changing its policy for Claude Code subscriptions, no longer allowing users to use their subscription limits for third-party harnesses like OpenClaw. Users can still use these tools with their Claude account, but they will require extra usage, billed separately from their subscription. This change is intended to manage demand and prioritize customers using Anthropic's core products. The company is offering a one-time credit for extra usage and discounts for pre-purchasing bundles of extra usage.

Main themes

  • Subscription policy changes
  • Third-party harnesses
  • Token consumption
  • Capacity management
  • Pricing models

What commenters say

  • Anthropic's policy change is seen as an attempt to restrict users from fully utilizing their subscription limits with third-party tools, and instead push them towards using the company's own products.
  • Some users argue that they are paying for a certain amount of token consumption, and should be able to use those tokens as they see fit, regardless of the tool used.
  • Others believe that the subscription model is designed to provide access to Anthropic's products, not just tokens, and that users should not expect to be able to use those tokens with third-party tools.
  • The policy change is viewed by some as a money grab, and an attempt to force users into paying more for extra usage or switching to a different pricing model.
  • Some commenters think that Anthropic should be more transparent about their pricing and capacity limits, and offer more flexible options for users who need to use third-party tools.
  • There is disagreement about whether the policy change unfairly impacts startups and developers who rely on third-party harnesses, or if it is a necessary step to manage demand and ensure the sustainability of Anthropic's business model.