news.volyx.in

How far back in time can you understand English? (deadlanguagesociety.com)

793 points by spzb · 149 days ago · 415 comments on HN

Article summary

The article presents an experiment where a blog post's language changes over time, starting from modern English and going back to Old English, to test how far back in time a reader can understand English. The post's language, spelling, and grammar change with each time period, making it increasingly difficult to comprehend. The author discusses the stability of written English over the last 300 years and how the voice and format of writing have changed faster than the language itself. The article invites readers to reflect on their own ability to understand English from different time periods.

Main themes

  • language evolution
  • English comprehension
  • regional accents
  • language learning
  • cultural influences
  • communication barriers

What commenters say

  • Some readers found they could understand English up to 1300, while others struggled with texts from the 19th century.
  • Knowing other languages, such as German or Dutch, can help with understanding older English texts.
  • Regional accents and dialects can significantly impact the comprehensibility of spoken English, even for native speakers.
  • Non-native speakers' accents can be easier to understand due to their simpler vocabulary and slower speech.
  • Individual variations in accent and language use within large groups, such as Indians, should not be overlooked.
  • Exposure to different accents and languages can improve one's ability to understand them over time.
  • The influence of native languages on English pronunciation and vocabulary can vary greatly across regions and countries.
  • The use of subtitles or interpretation can be necessary to facilitate communication between people with strong accents or dialects.