news.volyx.in

The struggle of resizing windows on macOS Tahoe (noheger.at)

2752 points by happosai · 192 days ago · 1207 comments on HN

Article summary

The article discusses the difficulties of resizing windows on macOS Tahoe due to the large corner radius, which can lead to failed attempts to resize windows. The issue arises because the clickable area for resizing is small and often lies outside the visible window corner. This design choice is seen as a usability issue, rather than just an aesthetic problem. The author argues that this is a new problem that has arisen with macOS Tahoe.

Main themes

  • macOS usability issues
  • Window resizing difficulties
  • Design vs functionality
  • Comparison to other operating systems
  • User interface design

What commenters say

  • The large corner radius in macOS Tahoe makes it difficult to resize windows, leading to a poor user experience.
  • The design choice of macOS Tahoe prioritizes aesthetics over functionality, which can be frustrating for users.
  • Some users prefer to use keyboard shortcuts or third-party applications to resize windows, rather than relying on the built-in functionality.
  • The issue with window resizing in macOS Tahoe is not unique to this operating system, as other systems like Linux have similar problems.
  • The decision to change the window resizing behavior in macOS Tahoe is seen as a misstep by some users, who prefer the previous behavior.
  • Some users argue that the problem can be solved by implementing features like alt-dragging or right-clicking to resize windows, similar to some Linux distributions.
  • Others argue that the issue is not with the design, but with the user's expectations and habits, and that they should adapt to the new behavior.
  • The discussion highlights the trade-offs between design and functionality, and the importance of considering user experience in software design.