news.volyx.in

No I don't want to turn on Windows Backup with One Drive (idiallo.com)

580 points by firefoxd · 286 days ago · 446 comments on HN

Article summary

The article discusses the author's frustration with Windows constantly prompting to turn on Windows Backup with OneDrive, feeling that there is no clear option to decline the service. The author believes this is an example of dark patterns, where the user is given the illusion of choice but is ultimately pushed towards a specific option. The author is looking for a way to permanently decline the service. The issue is part of a broader problem of Windows integrating OneDrive deeply into the operating system.

Main themes

  • Windows Backup and OneDrive
  • Dark patterns in software design
  • User autonomy and choice
  • Windows integration and bloat
  • Alternative backup solutions

What commenters say

  • Windows File History is a viable alternative to Windows Backup that does not require OneDrive, and can be used to backup files to an external drive or network location.
  • Some users prefer to use third-party backup solutions rather than relying on Microsoft's built-in options, citing better functionality and flexibility.
  • The integration of OneDrive into Windows is seen as an example of the operating system's bloat and lack of respect for user autonomy, with some users feeling forced into using the service.
  • Linux is proposed as a viable alternative to Windows for users who value simplicity, stability, and control over their operating system, with some distributions being more suitable for new users than others.
  • The use of dark patterns in software design is a widespread problem that extends beyond Windows, with other operating systems and companies also engaging in similar practices.
  • There is disagreement among users about the suitability of Linux distributions such as Linux Mint, with some praising its simplicity and stability, while others criticize its outdated software and lack of support for modern features like Wayland.