news.volyx.in

Microsoft is plugging more holes that let you use Windows 11 without MS account (theverge.com)

624 points by josephcsible · 292 days ago · 1353 comments on HN

Article summary

Microsoft is removing workarounds that allowed users to create local accounts on Windows 11 without an internet connection, requiring users to complete the setup process with a Microsoft account. This change is intended to ensure that users fully configure their devices for use. The company is also adding a way to name the default user folder during setup, although this feature requires a command. The move is seen as part of Microsoft's efforts to push users towards more secure hardware and software configurations.

Main themes

  • Windows 11 setup process
  • Microsoft account requirements
  • Secure Boot and TPM
  • User freedom and control
  • Corporate vs personal use
  • Security and updates

What commenters say

  • Microsoft's push for secure hardware and software configurations is seen as a way to force users to upgrade to newer devices, rather than a genuine concern for security.
  • The requirement for a Microsoft account and secure boot is unnecessary for personal users and only benefits corporate interests.
  • Some users believe that the benefits of Secure Boot and TPM are overstated and do not provide significant security benefits for ordinary consumers.
  • Others argue that Microsoft's security features are actually a form of control, restricting user freedom and paving the way for more invasive DRM and locked-down systems.
  • There is a concern that Microsoft's actions will drive users to seek out alternative operating systems, such as Linux, which offer more flexibility and control.
  • Some commenters believe that the EU's approach to regulating tech companies has been ineffective, allowing companies like Apple to find loopholes and maintain control over their ecosystems.
  • The use of third-party OSes and modification of Windows installations is seen as a reasonable response to Microsoft's restrictive policies, but also carries risks of malware and instability.
  • The line between legitimate software and malware is blurred when companies like Microsoft engage in data collection and surveillance, raising questions about trust and accountability.