news.volyx.in

Help us raise $200k to free JavaScript from Oracle (deno.com)

714 points by kaladin-jasnah · 311 days ago · 345 comments on HN

Article summary

Deno has initiated a petition to cancel Oracle's trademark on the term 'JavaScript' and is seeking $200,000 in donations to support the legal case. The petition argues that 'JavaScript' is a generic term and should be available for use by all developers. If successful, the term would become public domain. The case is currently in the discovery phase, with Oracle denying that 'JavaScript' is a generic term.

Main themes

  • JavaScript trademark
  • Oracle's claim
  • Deno's petition
  • Generic term debate
  • Programming language naming
  • Trademark law

What commenters say

  • The name 'JavaScript' is confusing and should be changed to avoid association with Java.
  • The term 'JavaScript' is generic and should not be trademarked by any company.
  • The legal case is unlikely to succeed due to the current political climate and the complexity of trademark law.
  • The name 'JavaScript' is not a significant issue and does not cause confusion among developers.
  • Using 'JS' or 'ECMAScript' instead of 'JavaScript' could help avoid trademark issues and confusion.
  • The trademark system is flawed and allows companies to squat on commonly-used names.
  • Donating to the cause may not be the most effective way to spend money, and there are better ways to address the issue.
  • The case has broader implications for trademark law and the use of generic terms in the tech industry.