news.volyx.in

Do not download the app, use the website (idiallo.com)

1347 points by foxfired · 368 days ago · 728 comments on HN

Article summary

The article discusses how companies push users to download their mobile apps instead of using their websites, and how this can lead to a loss of user privacy and control. The author argues that apps often request access to sensitive information such as location, contacts, and microphone, which can be used to collect data and track user behavior. In contrast, websites have limited access to user data and are subject to stricter regulations. The author concludes that users should prefer using websites over apps to protect their privacy.

Main themes

  • Mobile apps vs websites
  • User privacy and data collection
  • Company motivations and monetization
  • Native apps vs web apps
  • User control and agency

What commenters say

  • Some commenters argue that native apps provide a better user experience than web apps, with features like offline play and keyboard shortcuts.
  • Others claim that companies prioritize app development over web development, leading to a inferior web experience.
  • A few commenters suggest that the push for apps is driven by companies' desire to collect user data and track behavior, rather than providing a better user experience.
  • Some argue that the web is capable of providing a good user experience, but companies intentionally limit its functionality to drive app adoption.
  • There is disagreement over whether Apple's restrictions on web apps, such as limited notification support, are a legitimate reason for companies to develop native apps.
  • A few commenters note that users can still protect their privacy by rejecting app permissions and using web apps instead.
  • Some argue that the convenience of apps comes at the cost of user privacy and control, and that users should be aware of the trade-offs they make when choosing to use an app.