news.volyx.in

Klein Bottle Amazon Brand Hijacking (2021) (kleinbottle.com)

445 points by sebg · 403 days ago · 285 comments on HN

Article summary

Cliff Stoll's Amazon listing for Klein bottles was hijacked by a foreign seller, Amvoom, which trademarked its name and used Amazon's Brand Registry to take over the listing. Amvoom redirected Stoll's positive reviews to its own product, a blackhead remover. Stoll was unable to edit his listing or sell his products on Amazon due to the hijacking. The issue was eventually resolved, but not before Stoll's inventory was depleted and his business was disrupted.

Main themes

  • Amazon brand hijacking
  • E-commerce platform accountability
  • Consumer protection
  • Small claims court efficacy
  • Legislative solutions
  • Corporate complacency

What commenters say

  • Taking a company like Amazon to small claims court may not be an effective way to resolve issues like brand hijacking.
  • Some argue that legislation is needed to address the systemic issues with Amazon's brand registry and seller interactions.
  • Others suggest that consumers can fight back by taking their business elsewhere and supporting smaller, independent sellers.
  • Small claims court may not be a viable option for resolving disputes with large companies like Amazon due to the potential for them to throw resources at the case.
  • Some believe that the only way to effect change is to hit Amazon in the wallet by cancelling subscriptions and taking business elsewhere.
  • There are concerns that pursuing legal action against a large company like Amazon can be a massive time and money sink, regardless of the outcome.
  • Some argue that Amazon's complacency towards these issues is a major problem and that other companies, like Walmart, have not done enough to address the issue of fake products.
  • Supporting smaller, independent sellers and avoiding Amazon may be a way to promote accountability and reduce the prevalence of fake or low-quality products.