By default, Signal doesn't recall (signal.org)

Article summary

Signal Desktop on Windows 11 now includes a 'Screen security' setting that prevents screenshots of Signal chats, in response to Microsoft's Recall feature, which captures screenshots of apps every few seconds. This setting is enabled by default to protect user privacy. Recall was initially met with backlash and was pulled, but has since been revamped and reintroduced. The Recall feature still poses a risk to privacy-preserving apps like Signal, prompting the implementation of this new setting.

Main themes

• privacy vs convenience
• DRM and security
• Microsoft Recall feature
• alternative operating systems
• trust and verification
• AI and data collection

What commenters say

• The use of DRM to protect against the operating system is seen as a necessary but ironic measure to ensure user privacy.
• Some commenters believe that Microsoft's Recall feature is not a significant threat to privacy, as it can be opted out of and stores data locally.
• Others argue that trusting any company or system is inherently risky and that alternatives to Microsoft products should be considered.
• There is disagreement over whether the Signal setting is 'easy to disable' and 'difficult to accidentally disable', with some seeing these as contradictory statements.
• The discussion highlights the tension between privacy, security, and convenience in the development of new features and technologies.
• Some argue that the structure of the IT industry and societal attitudes towards technology are the root causes of these privacy concerns, rather than individual companies like Microsoft.
• The use of local AI models and DRM is seen as a potential solution to protect user privacy, but also raises concerns about the balance between security and accessibility.