news.volyx.in

Utah becomes first US state to ban fluoride in its water (bbc.com)

505 points by Jimmc414 · 491 days ago · 1259 comments on HN

Article summary

Utah has become the first US state to ban the use of fluoride in its public water, citing concerns over potential health risks. The ban, signed into law by Governor Spencer Cox, will go into effect on May 7. Experts have criticized the move, arguing that it will have negative consequences for oral health, particularly for children. Fluoride has been added to US drinking water since 1945 to prevent cavities.

Main themes

  • Water fluoridation
  • Public health policy
  • Dental health
  • Government regulation
  • Scientific evidence
  • Health risks

What commenters say

  • The ban on fluoride in Utah's public water is based on pseudoscience and will have negative consequences for children's oral health.
  • Fluoride is not necessary in public water as people can get it from toothpaste and other sources, and individuals should have the right to opt out.
  • The levels of fluoride in US water are safe and beneficial, and the ban is unnecessary and misguided.
  • There is evidence suggesting that high levels of fluoride exposure may be associated with negative health effects, such as lower IQ scores and bone cancer, and therefore the ban is justified.
  • The decision to ban fluoride is a matter of personal choice and individual freedom, and the government should not dictate what is added to public water.
  • The scientific evidence on the safety and effectiveness of fluoride is clear, and the ban is a result of misinformation and misconceptions.
  • The ban will disproportionately affect low-income communities who may not have access to regular dental care and rely on public water for their fluoride intake.
  • The US should follow the example of other countries that have discontinued water fluoridation, citing concerns over potential health risks and the availability of alternative sources of fluoride.