news.volyx.in

Apple pulls data protection tool after UK government security row (bbc.com)

1770 points by helsinkiandrew · 528 days ago · 1068 comments on HN

Article summary

Apple has removed its Advanced Data Protection (ADP) feature from the UK due to a request from the UK government to access user data, which Apple opposes as it would create a 'backdoor' in its encryption service. The feature, which provides end-to-end encryption for user data, will no longer be available to new users in the UK, and existing users will have their access disabled at a later date. The move has sparked a debate about online security, privacy, and government access to user data. The UK government's request was made under the Investigatory Powers Act, which compels firms to provide information to law enforcement agencies.

Main themes

  • Data Protection
  • Encryption
  • Government Surveillance
  • Online Security
  • Privacy
  • Tech Regulation

What commenters say

  • Providing a backdoor for one government reduces the security and privacy of the service worldwide, so it's better to remove the feature altogether.
  • The UK government's request for access to user data is a threat to online security and privacy, and Apple's decision to remove ADP is a necessary step to protect users.
  • Creating a system that allows law enforcement to access encrypted data with a court order is possible without compromising security, and Apple should explore such options.
  • The removal of ADP in the UK sets a dangerous precedent, as it shows that companies will prioritize compliance with government requests over user privacy and security.
  • The debate around encryption and government access to user data is not a zero-sum game, and it's possible to balance security and privacy with law enforcement needs.
  • The UK's Investigatory Powers Act is an overreach of government power, and companies like Apple should resist such requests to protect user rights.
  • Apple's decision to remove ADP in the UK will not fully address the concerns around government access to user data, as the feature will still be available in other countries.
  • The removal of ADP is a blow to user privacy and security, and users should consider alternative solutions that prioritize encryption and security.