news.volyx.in

uBlock Origin GPL code being stolen by team behind Honey browser extension (old.reddit.com)

1057 points by extesy · 580 days ago · 444 comments on HN

Article summary

The team behind the Honey browser extension has been found to be stealing code from uBlock Origin, a popular ad blocker, and violating its GPL license. The stolen code is being used in their new ad blocker extension, Pie Adblock. This discovery has sparked outrage and discussion about the ethics of Honey's business practices and the enforcement of GPL licenses. The situation is seen as a clear case of copyright infringement and a violation of the principles of open-source software.

Main themes

  • GPL license violation
  • Code theft
  • Ad blocker ethics
  • Open-source software
  • Copyright infringement
  • Affiliate marketing

What commenters say

  • The Honey team's actions are a clear case of copyright infringement and a violation of the GPL license, and they should be held accountable.
  • The enforcement of GPL licenses is difficult and often relies on the copyright owners taking action, which can be a barrier to protecting open-source software.
  • Honey's business practices are unethical and harmful to content creators, who rely on affiliate marketing for income.
  • The issue with Honey's code theft is not just about the GPL license, but also about the company's lack of transparency and honesty with its users.
  • Some argue that the affiliate marketing industry is inherently flawed and that Honey's actions are just a symptom of a larger problem.
  • Others believe that Honey's actions are not unique and that other companies in the industry engage in similar practices, and that the focus should be on changing the industry as a whole.
  • The use of ad blockers and the promotion of open-source software are seen as ways to push back against unethical business practices and promote a more honest and transparent online ecosystem.
  • The situation highlights the need for greater awareness and education about open-source software, GPL licenses, and the importance of protecting intellectual property rights.