Touchscreens are out, and tactile controls are back (spectrum.ieee.org)

Article summary

The trend of using touchscreens in various devices, including cars and home appliances, is being reversed in favor of tactile controls, such as buttons and knobs. This shift, referred to as 're-buttonization', is driven by the desire for a more tactile experience and the limitations of touchscreens in certain situations. Companies are now seeking the expertise of Rachel Plotnick, a leading expert on buttons and their history, to improve their tactile controls. The return to physical controls is seen as a way to simplify interactions and reduce distractions, particularly in situations like driving.

Main themes

• Re-buttonization
• Tactile controls
• Touchscreen limitations
• User experience
• Design trends
• Accessibility

What commenters say

• The shift back to physical buttons is a welcome change, as they provide a more tactile and intuitive experience, especially in situations like driving or cooking.
• Touchscreens have their advantages, but they can be distracting and less safe in certain situations, making physical controls a better choice.
• The evolution of UI over time can be beneficial, but it can also break muscle memory and cause frustration, making it important to consider the trade-offs.
• Some argue that the move to physical buttons is a step backwards, and that touchscreens offer more flexibility and customization options.
• The use of capacitive touch sensing in appliances is seen as a cost-cutting measure rather than a design choice, and can lead to frustrating user experiences.
• There is a desire for assignable knobs and controls in vehicles, allowing drivers to customize their experience and reduce distractions.
• The introduction of new technologies and UI changes can have unintended consequences, such as encouraging reckless behavior, and companies should be held liable for damages.
• Physical controls can provide a sense of simplicity and ease of use, making them a preferable choice for many users, especially in everyday appliances.