news.volyx.in

Google removed Organic Maps from the Play Store (twitter.com)

608 points by faebi · 722 days ago · 224 comments on HN

Article summary

Organic Maps, an app that uses OpenStreetMap data, was removed from the Google Play Store without warning due to not meeting the requirements for the Family Program. The app's developers are appealing the decision and have provided a temporary workaround for users to install the app. The removal has sparked discussion about Google's review process and potential anti-competitive behavior. The app is still available on other platforms, including F-Droid.

Main themes

  • Google Play Store policies
  • OpenStreetMap apps
  • Anti-competitive behavior
  • App review process
  • Alternative app stores

What commenters say

  • Google's automated review process is flawed and can lead to unjustified app removals.
  • The removal of Organic Maps may be due to its ability to display sensitive information, such as the location of brothels, which could be considered inappropriate for children.
  • Google's actions are an example of anti-competitive behavior, and the company should be held accountable for its dominance in the app market.
  • The removal of Organic Maps highlights the importance of alternative app stores, such as F-Droid, which offer more freedom and flexibility for developers and users.
  • Twitter's platform is not suitable for sharing and discussing complex information, and its limitations make it a poor choice for linking to relevant discussions.
  • The decision to stop linking to Twitter is justified due to its hostile UX for non-users, which limits access to information and discussion.
  • Google's review process is not transparent, and the company should provide more detailed explanations for its decisions to remove apps from the Play Store.
  • The availability of Organic Maps on other platforms, such as F-Droid, mitigates the impact of its removal from the Google Play Store.