news.volyx.in

Creativity fundamentally comes from memorization? (shwin.co)

463 points by shw1n · 740 days ago · 360 comments on HN

Article summary

The article argues that creativity fundamentally comes from memorization, as it allows individuals to internalize patterns and concepts, enabling them to make connections and create novel ideas. The author shares their personal experience of using a system of memorization to learn new skills quickly and become more creative. They suggest that autonomy in multiple areas is key to becoming more creative, and that memorization plays a crucial role in achieving this autonomy. By internalizing knowledge, individuals can free up their attention to focus on higher-level problems and create new things.

Main themes

  • Creativity and Memorization
  • Learning and Autonomy
  • Pattern Recognition
  • Internalized Knowledge
  • Tacit Knowledge

What commenters say

  • Memorization is a necessary step in the creative process, as it allows individuals to internalize patterns and concepts, enabling them to make connections and create novel ideas.
  • Some argue that creativity comes from applying acquired knowledge in new contexts, rather than just memorization, and that pattern matching is a distinct process from memorization.
  • Others propose that taste and elegance in creative endeavors stem from an internalized heuristic, which is a form of memorization, while others disagree, suggesting that taste is something that can only be learned through experience and mentorship.
  • There is a distinction between rote memorization and organic or implicit memorization, with some arguing that the former can narrow understanding, while the latter is a more effective way to internalize information.
  • Some creatives argue that they do not rely on memorization, but rather on processing novel information and analyzing it to internalize insights and build models, allowing them to generate new ideas.
  • Others counter that this process of internalizing insights and building models is itself a form of memorization, and that the distinction between memorization and other forms of learning is not always clear-cut.
  • The role of tacit knowledge in creativity is also debated, with some arguing that it is essential, while others propose that all tacit knowledge can be made explicit, but is difficult to do so.
  • The definition of memorization is also contested, with some using it to describe a focused attempt at internalizing information, while others conflate it with rote memorization, which has negative connotations.