news.volyx.in

AeroSpace is an i3-like tiling window manager for macOS (github.com)

524 points by loughnane · 798 days ago · 168 comments on HN

Article summary

AeroSpace is a tiling window manager for macOS, inspired by i3, that offers features such as fast workspace switching, plain text configuration, and proper multi-monitor support. It does not require disabling System Integrity Protection (SIP) and is designed to be keyboard-centric. The project is currently in public beta and is being actively developed. AeroSpace aims to provide a practical and efficient window management experience for advanced users and developers.

Main themes

  • Tiling window managers
  • macOS window management
  • System Integrity Protection
  • Keyboard-centric workflow
  • Window management tools

What commenters say

  • Some users have had negative experiences with tiling window managers on macOS due to compatibility issues and quirky behavior.
  • AeroSpace's ability to work alongside SIP without requiring it to be disabled is a significant advantage over other window managers.
  • The use of tiling window managers on macOS is a losing battle due to the operating system's inherent limitations and tendency to override user preferences.
  • Some users prefer to adapt to the native macOS UI rather than trying to impose a different window management paradigm.
  • There are varying opinions on the effectiveness and usability of different window management tools, such as Yabai, Amethyst, and Rectangle.
  • Disabling SIP can be a significant security concern, and some users are hesitant to do so, even if it would allow for more advanced window management features.
  • The lack of certain features, such as focus-follows-mouse, in macOS is a significant drawback for some users.
  • Some users have found success with certain window management tools, such as Rectangle, and swear by their simplicity and effectiveness.