news.volyx.in

Signal: Will leave the EU market rather than undermine our privacy guarantees (twitter.com)

649 points by doener · 803 days ago · 626 comments on HN

Article summary

Signal's CEO has stated that the company will leave the EU market rather than comply with proposed regulations that would undermine its privacy guarantees. The proposal would require Signal to scan users' chats, which the company strongly opposes. Signal prioritizes user privacy and is willing to exit the EU market to maintain its standards. This decision is in response to the EU's proposed ChatControl regulation.

Main themes

  • EU ChatControl regulation
  • Signal's privacy guarantees
  • Encryption and surveillance
  • User data protection
  • Regulatory compliance

What commenters say

  • Signal's decision to leave the EU market is a necessary step to protect user privacy and maintain its integrity.
  • The proposed EU regulation is an overreach and threatens the privacy of users, and Signal is right to oppose it.
  • The inability to backup chats on iOS is a significant limitation of Signal, and the company's priorities are misplaced.
  • Alternative messaging apps, such as Threema, may not be viable options due to their own compliance with EU regulations.
  • The EU's proposed regulation is not about protecting users, but rather about boosting local industry through pseudo-tariffs.
  • Signal's stance on privacy is admirable, but its implementation, such as not allowing backups, can be frustrating for users.
  • The regulation will have far-reaching consequences for all secure messaging and communication platforms, not just Signal.
  • Users who value privacy should be free to choose how they manage their data, including storing it with third-party services.