news.volyx.in

Vector indexing all of Wikipedia on a laptop (foojay.io)

513 points by tjake · 806 days ago · 140 comments on HN

Article summary

The article discusses how to index all of Wikipedia on a laptop using the JVector library, which supports indexing larger-than-memory datasets. The library uses compressed vectors to reduce memory usage, allowing for efficient searching and indexing of large datasets. The author provides a step-by-step guide on how to build and search the index, including code examples and requirements for the project. The resulting index can be used for semantic search and other applications.

Main themes

  • Vector indexing
  • Wikipedia dataset
  • JVector library
  • Compressed vectors
  • Semantic search
  • Efficient indexing

What commenters say

  • The cost of computing embeddings for all of Wikipedia is estimated to be around $5000, but some commenters argue that it can be done for much cheaper using open models and Colab.
  • The use of proprietary embeddings, such as those provided by Cohere, may not be the best approach due to the lack of transparency and potential limitations.
  • Vector embedding is just one mechanism for achieving semantic similarity search, and other approaches, such as stemming and linguistic analysis, may still be relevant and effective.
  • The field of information retrieval is still relevant and useful, even with the advent of large language models and vector search.
  • The current state of LLM-based interfaces is immature and may not provide the best user experience, with some arguing that a more ground-up rethink of these interfaces is needed.
  • The economics of the web and the rise of LLMs may be disrupting the traditional publishing model, leading to concerns about the sustainability of high-quality information sources.