The FCC needs to stop 5G fast lanes (cyberlaw.stanford.edu)

Article summary

The FCC is set to vote on restoring its authority over internet service providers and reinstating net neutrality protections. The proposed rules aim to prevent ISPs from degrading video quality and allow states to enforce their own net neutrality laws. However, the rules also open the door for mobile ISPs to create 5G fast lanes, which could lead to ISPs picking winners and losers online. This could limit user choice, distort competition, and harm startups.

Main themes

• Net Neutrality
• 5G Fast Lanes
• ISP Regulation
• Internet Access
• Competition
• FCC Policy

What commenters say

• The main issue with US internet is the lack of competition due to monopolies, and the FCC should focus on breaking up infrastructure from retailers to promote competition.
• The US lags behind other developed countries in terms of internet access and speed, and this is evident when comparing prices and speeds in different countries.
• Some argue that the US is not a developed country in terms of infrastructure, education, and governance, despite being considered developed due to its wealth.
• Competition can lead to better internet deals, as seen in some US cities where multiple providers offer high-speed internet at lower prices.
• The FCC's proposed rules are insufficient, as they do not explicitly prohibit ISPs from creating fast lanes and may lead to a case-by-case approach that favors large corporations.
• Regulation of large businesses and local government-run non-profit ISPs can provide a sensible baseline for internet access and promote competition.
• Comparing internet access in the US to other countries is not always fair, as it depends on various factors such as income and urban vs. rural areas.
• Some commenters argue that their personal internet experience is good, but this may not be representative of the overall state of internet access in the US.