news.volyx.in

Show HN: Boardzilla, a framework for making web-based board games (boardzilla.io)

574 points by joshbuddy · 932 days ago · 105 comments on HN

Article summary

Boardzilla is a framework for creating web-based board games, allowing developers to express game rules and provide players with a simple interface. The platform currently hosts several games, including 7 Wonders Duel and Power Grid. Boardzilla aims to make it easy to develop and play digital board games within a browser. The project is open-source and provides a API for building games.

Main themes

  • board game development
  • open-source licensing
  • game mechanics and copyright
  • competition with existing platforms
  • security features
  • branding and naming
  • programming languages and documentation
  • self-hosting and local development

What commenters say

  • The use of the Commons Clause license is criticized for being overly restrictive, and AGPLv3 is suggested as a more suitable alternative.
  • The project's potential for success is hindered by the dominance of existing platforms, such as Board Game Arena, which is owned by Asmodee.
  • Game mechanics cannot be copyrighted, but using similar names or artwork without permission can still be problematic.
  • The project's focus on indie games and smaller publishers may be a viable way to avoid direct competition with established platforms.
  • The lack of security features, such as protection against rage quitting or cheating, is a concern for the project's long-term success.
  • The name 'Boardzilla' may infringe on the Godzilla copyright, and changing the name or negotiating a deal with the copyright holder may be necessary.
  • The project's use of TypeScript is questioned, and the addition of more documentation and features, such as support for simultaneous actions, is seen as a positive aspect.
  • The project's potential for self-hosting and local development is a valuable feature, but may not be immediately clear to users.