news.volyx.in

Whisky: Wine supercharged with the power of Apple's game porting toolkit (getwhisky.app)

435 points by robin_reala · 1000 days ago · 156 comments on HN

Article summary

Whisky is a tool that uses Apple's Game Porting Toolkit to allow Mac users to play Windows games on their devices. It provides a hands-off setup experience and native UI, making it easy for users to play games like Baldur's Gate 3 and Cyberpunk 2077. However, the project is no longer maintained, and users are advised to buy CrossOver instead. Whisky relies on Rosetta 2 to translate x86 binaries to ARM binaries, allowing x86 games to run on macOS.

Main themes

  • Game Porting Toolkit
  • Rosetta 2
  • Mac Gaming
  • Legacy Support
  • Cross-Platform Compatibility
  • Tool Naming and Branding

What commenters say

  • Some users prefer alternative game launchers like Heroic Game Launcher, which offers more features and flexibility.
  • The future of Rosetta 2 is uncertain, and Apple may drop support for it in the future, rendering Whisky and similar tools obsolete.
  • Dropping Rosetta 2 would force developers to transition to native ARM support, but it would also limit the capabilities of tools like Crossover and Docker.
  • The name 'Whisky' is misleading, as it implies a transformation of wine into whisky, which is not possible, and a more accurate name like 'Port' or 'Brandy' would be more fitting.
  • Apple's historical precedent suggests that they may drop support for legacy architectures and technologies, including Rosetta 2, in favor of newer and more efficient solutions.
  • The maintenance of Rosetta 2 is costly, and Apple may eventually drop it to focus on more profitable and widely-used technologies.
  • The discussion around Whisky and Rosetta 2 highlights the complexities and challenges of supporting legacy games and software on modern macOS devices.