news.volyx.in

Instead of collaborating or supporting me, Google stole my idea (github.com)

547 points by FloatArtifact · 1075 days ago · 109 comments on HN

Article summary

The author of the open-source project Handsfree.js claims that Google stole their idea after they shared it with a Google employee. The author had been working on the project while homeless and struggling with mental health issues. They feel validated that Google has made progress on a similar project, but are also upset that they did not receive support or recognition for their work. The author's story has sparked a discussion about the ethics of large corporations using open-source ideas without compensating the creators.

Main themes

  • Intellectual property
  • Corporate ethics
  • Open-source software
  • Compensation for creators
  • Power dynamics between individuals and corporations

What commenters say

  • Google should respond to the author's claims and consider compensating them for their work.
  • The author's idea was open-source and therefore not protected by intellectual property laws.
  • Corporations have a responsibility to treat individuals fairly and compensate them for their contributions.
  • The author's experience is an example of how large corporations can take advantage of individual creators.
  • The fact that Google did not break any laws does not mean that their actions were ethical.
  • Individuals can influence the actions of corporations and promote positive change.
  • Corporations are primarily motivated by profit and will prioritize their own interests over fairness and ethics.