news.volyx.in

OpenTF announces fork of Terraform (opentf.org)

1711 points by cube2222 · 1096 days ago · 486 comments on HN

Article summary

The article discusses the announcement of OpenTF, a fork of Terraform, following HashiCorp's decision to change the license of Terraform to a non-open source one. This change prevents companies from using Terraform to build commercial products around it. The fork is seen as a response to this change, with some arguing that it is necessary to preserve the open-source nature of Terraform. The discussion around the fork and the license change is ongoing, with various opinions on the matter.

Main themes

  • Open-source licensing
  • Community contributions
  • Commercialization of open-source software
  • Forking and community schism
  • License agreements and contributor rights
  • Business models for open-source software

What commenters say

  • HashiCorp's license change is seen as a betrayal of the open-source community that contributed to Terraform.
  • The new license is not as restrictive as some claim, and companies can still use Terraform for non-commercial purposes.
  • The fork is necessary to prevent HashiCorp from controlling the development of Terraform and limiting its use.
  • Some contributors feel that their work has been exploited by HashiCorp, and the license change is a result of this exploitation.
  • The license change is a legitimate business decision by HashiCorp to protect their commercial interests.
  • The fork may lead to a schism in the community and create competing tools that are not interoperable.
  • Contributors who signed contributor license agreements may have inadvertently given up their rights to control the use of their contributions.