news.volyx.in

Google’s nightmare “Web Integrity API” wants a DRM gatekeeper for the web (arstechnica.com)

1090 points by jakobdabo · 1129 days ago · 465 comments on HN

Article summary

Google has proposed a new web standard called the Web Integrity API, which aims to verify the integrity of a user's browser environment. The API would allow websites to require users to pass an 'environment attestation' test before accessing certain content. This test would verify that the user's browser has not been modified or tampered with in any way. The proposal has sparked controversy and debate among developers and users.

Main themes

  • Web Integrity API
  • browser freedom
  • online security
  • DRM and gatekeeping
  • open web
  • user control

What commenters say

  • The Web Integrity API is a threat to the open web and will lead to a loss of user control and freedom.
  • The API is necessary to prevent cheating and ensure the security of online transactions.
  • Websites that require the API will drive users away and ultimately harm their own interests.
  • The proposal is part of a larger trend towards a more locked-down and controlled internet.
  • The API will disproportionately affect independent browser development and smaller websites.
  • Users will find ways to circumvent the API and maintain their control over their browsing experience.
  • The API is a form of DRM that will stifle innovation and creativity on the web.
  • The proposal is a slippery slope that will lead to further gatekeeping and censorship on the internet.