news.volyx.in

Self-hosted photo and video backups directly from your mobile phone (github.com)

757 points by barbazoo · 1144 days ago · 344 comments on HN

Article summary

Immich is a self-hosted photo and video management solution that allows users to backup their media directly from their mobile phones. The project is still under active development and warns of potential bugs and breaking changes. It features facial recognition, a map, and sharing folders publicly or with other users on the server. The solution is designed to be a high-performance alternative to cloud-based services like Google Photos.

Main themes

  • self-hosted photo management
  • backup and sync
  • facial recognition
  • end-to-end encryption
  • multi-user support
  • resource efficiency

What commenters say

  • Some users are hesitant to use Immich due to its instability and potential bugs, despite its promising features.
  • Others have successfully switched to Immich from Google Photos and iCloud, citing its reliability and self-hosting capabilities.
  • The lack of end-to-end encryption and multi-user support are major drawbacks for some potential users.
  • Single-user instances and self-hosting can be beneficial for security and control, but may not be practical for families or groups.
  • Some commenters are working on similar projects, prioritizing features like end-to-end encryption and on-device face recognition.
  • The resource requirements of modern photo management software are increasing, leading to slower performance and higher hardware demands.
  • Older software like Picasa was able to perform similar tasks with much lower resource requirements, prompting questions about the efficiency of modern tech stacks.
  • The trade-off between security, functionality, and usability is a major consideration for users choosing a photo management solution.