news.volyx.in

If PEP 703 is accepted, Meta can commit three engineer-years to no-GIL CPython (discuss.python.org)

656 points by bratao · 1146 days ago · 441 comments on HN

Article summary

Meta has offered to commit three engineer-years to help implement a no-GIL version of CPython if PEP 703 is accepted. The engineers will work with the core development team to ensure a smooth implementation. This offer is in response to a request for help from the Python community. The goal is to improve Python's performance and compatibility.

Main themes

  • Corporate involvement in open-source
  • Conflict of interest
  • Python performance and compatibility
  • GIL removal and parallelism
  • Open-source community dynamics
  • Corporate contributions to open-source projects

What commenters say

  • Meta's offer of engineer time is a valuable contribution to the Python community, but some question the potential conflict of interest.
  • The removal of the GIL will greatly benefit certain domains, such as machine learning, by allowing for true parallelism.
  • Some argue that Meta's offer is not a donation, but rather a smart business move to improve Python for their own use cases.
  • Others believe that the offer is not equivalent to a monetary sponsorship and should not be seen as a guarantee of acceptance for PEP 703.
  • The discussion around Meta's offer highlights the complexities of corporate involvement in open-source projects.
  • Some commenters are concerned that Meta's interests may not align with those of the broader Python community.
  • Others argue that the offer is a positive development, as it shows Meta's commitment to improving Python and contributing to the open-source community.