news.volyx.in

Fast machines, slow machines (jmmv.dev)

597 points by _dain_ · 1156 days ago · 346 comments on HN

Article summary

The article discusses the issue of latency in modern computer interfaces, comparing the responsiveness of old computers running Windows NT 3.51 with new computers running Windows 11. The author argues that despite significant advancements in hardware, UI latency has worsened over time. The article also explores the potential causes of this issue and possible solutions. The author's Twitter thread on the topic went viral, sparking a discussion about the trade-offs between features, performance, and user experience.

Main themes

  • UI latency
  • desktop environments
  • window managers
  • UI animations
  • cross-platform frameworks
  • user experience trade-offs

What commenters say

  • Some commenters argue that certain desktop environments and window managers, such as i3 and XFCE, offer a snappier user experience than others, like Gnome and KDE.
  • There is a desire for more control over UI animations, with some users wanting to disable specific animations, like desktop switching, without affecting others.
  • The use of Electron and other cross-platform frameworks is seen as a contributor to poor performance in some applications, but others defend their use as a necessary trade-off for development efficiency.
  • Disabling animations and using keyboard shortcuts can improve the user experience, but some users prefer the visual feedback provided by animations and do not find them intrusive.
  • The responsiveness of an operating system is influenced by a combination of factors, including hardware, software, and user configuration.
  • Some users prefer a more minimalist approach to UI design, with fewer features and animations, while others value the visual appeal and functionality provided by modern desktop environments.