news.volyx.in

I criticized Amazon’s policies in a blog – their lawyers have subpoenaed me (twitter.com)

922 points by graeme · 1186 days ago · 222 comments on HN

Article summary

A blogger who criticized Amazon's policies has been subpoenaed by the company's lawyers, allegedly as part of a lawsuit. The blogger claims that Amazon's lawyers are trying to ruin him. The situation is related to a lawsuit by the state of California against Amazon, in which the blogger is a witness. Amazon's lawyers are requesting documents from the blogger as part of the discovery process.

Main themes

  • Corporate intimidation
  • Legal abuse
  • Free speech
  • Discovery process
  • Lawsuit reform
  • Corporate accountability

What commenters say

  • The situation is an example of a large company using its resources to intimidate and silence a critic.
  • The blogger should have expected legal consequences when testifying against Amazon in a lawsuit.
  • The discovery process is being abused by Amazon to overwhelm the blogger with document requests.
  • The blogger's claims about Amazon's policies may be dubious and difficult to support with evidence.
  • The situation highlights the need for 'loser pays' tort reform to prevent companies from using lawsuits to harass critics.
  • The blogger's legal bills should be covered by the state of California, which is using him as a witness in the lawsuit.
  • The discovery process is a normal part of a lawsuit, and the blogger's complaints are unfounded.
  • Amazon's actions may be a form of denial-of-service attack, intended to drown the blogger in document requests and legal fees.