The EARN IT bill is back, seeking to scan our messages and photos (eff.org)

Article summary

The EARN IT Act is a proposed US law that could lead to the scanning of online messages, photos, and files for child sexual abuse material, potentially compromising user privacy and end-to-end encryption. The law would create a government commission to establish best practices for internet companies, which could include scanning user data. Critics argue that the law's language does not adequately protect encryption and could lead to false accusations and abuse. The Electronic Frontier Foundation is urging people to take action against the bill.

Main themes

• privacy rights
• government surveillance
• end-to-end encryption
• child sexual abuse material
• online regulation
• corporate interests
• individual responsibility
• security vs privacy trade-off

What commenters say

• The constant attempts to pass the EARN IT Act are an erosion of privacy rights.
• People are becoming desensitized to attacks on their privacy, which makes it easier for such laws to pass.
• Large corporations may benefit from such legislation as it would create barriers to entry for smaller competitors.
• Some argue that individuals can protect their privacy by making conscious choices about the technology they use and the data they share.
• The trade-off between privacy and security is a complex issue with no clear solution.
• The EARN IT Act is seen as part of a broader trend of governments increasingly seeking to monitor and control online activity.
• There is a concern that the legislation could lead to a slippery slope where more and more online activities are monitored and restricted.
• Individuals should be proactive in defending their privacy rights rather than relying on others to do so.