news.volyx.in

There's something off about LED bulbs (nymag.com)

701 points by brainfog · 1250 days ago · 942 comments on HN

Article summary

The article discusses the author's dissatisfaction with LED bulbs, citing issues such as flickering, color temperature, and dimming problems. The author notes that while LEDs are energy-efficient and environmentally friendly, they often fail to provide the same quality of light as traditional incandescent bulbs. The US government has implemented a ban on incandescent bulbs, making LEDs the only available option. As a result, the author believes that good lighting may become a luxury product, accessible only to those who can afford high-quality LEDs.

Main themes

  • LED bulb quality
  • Dimming and color temperature
  • Energy efficiency and environmental impact
  • Lighting technology and innovation
  • Consumer choice and accessibility

What commenters say

  • Some commenters argue that non-dimmable LEDs are the primary cause of the author's problems and that dimmable bulbs are a better option.
  • Others disagree, stating that they have never understood the need for dimming lights and prefer a simple on/off switch.
  • A few commenters mention that the color temperature of LEDs can be a problem, with some bulbs appearing too blue or cold, while others appreciate the warm tone of certain LED bulbs.
  • Some argue that the quality of LEDs has improved significantly in recent years, with many options now available for warm and dimmable lighting.
  • Others express frustration with the complexity of choosing the right LED bulb, citing issues with compatibility, color rendering, and dimming.
  • A few commenters note that the energy efficiency of LEDs is a significant advantage, and that the environmental benefits outweigh any minor drawbacks.
  • Some commenters also mention that the ban on incandescent bulbs may lead to a black market for them, with some companies selling them as 'heaters' to circumvent the ban.