Disqualified from a National Web Design Competition for Using GitHub (medium.com)

Article summary

A participant in a national web design competition was disqualified for using GitHub, with the judges apparently considering it a template engine. The participant's project was hosted on GitHub Pages, but used self-crafted HTML, not templates. The disqualification has sparked a discussion about the judges' technical literacy and the rules of the competition. The project's code is publicly available, showing that it was not generated by a template engine.

Main themes

• technical literacy
• competition rules
• version control systems
• web development
• judging criteria
• GitHub and GitHub Pages

What commenters say

• The judges' decision was likely due to a lack of technical understanding, as GitHub is not a template engine, but a version control system.
• The competition rules should be clearer about what is and is not allowed, to avoid similar disqualifications in the future.
• The participant's use of GitHub Pages does not necessarily imply the use of a template engine, and the judges should have looked closer at the code.
• The disqualification is an example of incompetence on the part of the contest and judges, who failed to understand the technology used.
• The ability to use version control systems like GitHub is an important skill for developers, and should not be discouraged.
• The judges' decision may have been based on a misunderstanding of the difference between GitHub and GitHub Pages.
• The competition should focus on the quality of the code and the project, rather than the tools used to create it.
• The disqualification is a learning experience for the participant, who can use it to improve their skills and prepare for future competitions.