news.volyx.in

Hundreds of changes made to latest editions of Roald Dahl's books (telegraph.co.uk)

544 points by GavCo · 1292 days ago · 905 comments on HN

Article summary

The latest editions of Roald Dahl's books have undergone hundreds of changes, including the removal of references to certain authors and the alteration of language to better fit modern sensibilities. The changes have sparked a discussion about censorship and the impact of editing on the original work. The edits have been made to make the books more suitable for contemporary readers. The original article is not available, but the discussion reveals a range of opinions on the matter.

Main themes

  • censorship
  • editing classic literature
  • cultural sensitivity
  • children's books
  • modern sensibilities
  • cultural stagnation

What commenters say

  • Editing classic children's books to fit modern sensibilities is a form of censorship that undermines the original work.
  • The changes made to Roald Dahl's books are necessary to make them more accessible and enjoyable for contemporary readers.
  • The removal of references to certain authors, such as Rudyard Kipling, is a loss of cultural heritage and historical context.
  • The editing of classic books is a common practice that does not constitute censorship, but rather a necessary step in making the work relevant to new audiences.
  • The focus on editing classic books rather than creating new ones may be a sign of cultural stagnation.
  • The rise of new media has led to a decline in the appreciation and consumption of old media, including classic children's books.
  • The decision to edit Roald Dahl's books is a reflection of a broader cultural shift towards greater sensitivity and awareness of social issues.
  • The edits made to the books are not significant enough to alter the overall message and impact of the stories.