news.volyx.in

Windows 11: a spyware machine out of users' control (techspot.com)

485 points by jlpcsl · 1303 days ago · 348 comments on HN

Article summary

A recent video analyzed the network traffic of a freshly installed Windows 11 system and found that it makes numerous connections to third-party servers, including market research companies and advertising providers, without user permission or intervention. The connections are made for telemetry and data collection purposes. The behavior is compared to Windows XP, which only contacts the Windows Update service after installation. The findings have raised concerns about user privacy and data collection by Microsoft.

Main themes

  • Windows 11 telemetry
  • user privacy
  • data collection
  • Microsoft transparency
  • alternative operating systems
  • tech industry practices

What commenters say

  • Some commenters argue that the data being sent is likely encrypted and its contents are unknown, making it difficult to determine the extent of the data collection.
  • Others believe that the connections to third-party servers are unnecessary and potentially intrusive, even if the data being sent is not sensitive.
  • A few commenters suggest that the data collection is necessary for providing certain services, such as news and weather widgets, and that it is a common practice in the tech industry.
  • Some argue that users should have more control over the data being collected and sent, and that the lack of transparency is a concern.
  • A few commenters propose that using alternative operating systems, such as Linux, may be a way to avoid such data collection.
  • Others argue that the benefits of using Windows, such as security patches and updates, outweigh the potential privacy concerns.