How many layers of UI inconsistencies are in Windows 11? (ntdotdev.wordpress.com)

Article summary

The article discusses the various layers of UI inconsistencies in Windows 11, ranging from Windows 11/WinUI3 elements to remnants of Windows 3.1. The author notes that while there have been improvements in design consistency, there is still room for improvement. The article highlights the presence of outdated UI elements from previous Windows versions, including Windows 10, 8, 7, Vista, XP, 2000, and 95/NT 4.0. The author concludes that Microsoft has made progress, but there is still work to be done to achieve a consistent UI.

Main themes

• UI consistency
• Windows 11 design
• Microsoft's design decisions
• User experience
• Functionality vs aesthetics
• Third-party tools
• Customizability
• Influence of other OS designs

What commenters say

• Some users believe that Microsoft should prioritize functionality over UI updates.
• Others argue that a consistent UI is important for a good user experience.
• The removal of features and settings in Windows 11 is seen as a negative by some users.
• There is disagreement over the effectiveness of Windows 8's UI design.
• Some users are willing to pay for software that meets their needs, while others prefer free or open-source alternatives.
• The use of third-party tools to fix UI issues in Windows 11 is seen as a necessary workaround by some users.
• There is a perception that Microsoft's design team is influenced by macOS and that this has led to a less customizable UI.
• The decision to remove certain features and settings in Windows 11 is seen as a mistake by some users, who believe that these features were useful and should have been retained.