news.volyx.in

NY Sabotages Right to Repair Bill [video] (youtube.com)

427 points by asjfkdlf · 1347 days ago · 331 comments on HN

Article summary

The article discusses the New York Right to Repair bill, which was sabotaged by Governor Kathy Hochul. The original bill passed by the state legislature would have required OEMs to sell individual components, but the amended version only requires them to do what they are already doing. The amendment was made without a vote from the legislature, which is not currently in session. The exact mechanism of how this happened is unclear, with some questioning the authority and process behind the changes.

Main themes

  • Right to Repair
  • Regulatory Capture
  • Corruption
  • New York State Politics
  • Democracy and Transparency
  • Corporate Influence

What commenters say

  • The governor's amendment to the Right to Repair bill undermines its original intent and benefits corporate interests.
  • The legislature shares blame for the amendment, as they allegedly agreed to the changes.
  • The amendment process was undemocratic and lacked transparency, with some questioning the authority behind the changes.
  • The bill's failure to pass in its original form is a result of regulatory capture and corruption.
  • The only way to pass a real Right to Repair bill is through a ballot measure, as the legislative route is too influenced by corporate interests.
  • The governor's actions are a continuation of a pattern of behavior in New York state politics, where bills are often sabotaged or vetoed due to personal or corporate interests.
  • The lack of transparency and accountability in the amendment process is a concern for democracy and the rule of law.