news.volyx.in

Why “go nuts, show nuts” doesn’t work in 2022 (photomatt.tumblr.com)

758 points by firloop · 1440 days ago · 674 comments on HN

Article summary

The article discusses why the 'go nuts, show nuts' policy of Tumblr, a social media platform, is no longer viable in 2022. The main reasons include the anti-porn stance of credit card companies and app stores, particularly Apple's, as well as the need for verifying consent and age in adult content. The author, who is the founder of WordPress and owner of Tumblr, explains that the platform cannot afford to lose access to credit card processing and app stores. As a result, the 'go nuts, show nuts' era of the early internet is impossible to maintain today.

Main themes

  • adult content regulation
  • credit card companies and porn
  • app store policies
  • internet freedom and censorship
  • societal values and cultural norms
  • commercialization of the internet

What commenters say

  • Credit card companies' anti-porn stance is driven by risk assessment rather than political ideology.
  • The rise of mobile phones and app stores has led to a more closed and restrictive internet environment.
  • The porn industry has a history of exploiting and abusing individuals, which contributes to its stigma and restriction.
  • The issue of adult content on social media platforms is closely tied to broader societal values and cultural norms.
  • Some argue that the credit card companies' decision to drop adult services is a result of political pressure and lobbying.
  • Others believe that the problem lies not with hackers or the public, but with the increasing commercialization and regulation of the internet.
  • There is a need for a 'show nuts' compliance platform to standardize practices and auditing for nudity and porn on social networks.
  • The restriction of adult content on mobile devices is seen as a form of censorship and a step backward in terms of freedom of expression.