news.volyx.in

3x new books added to the Pirate Library Mirror (annas-blog.org)

624 points by pilimi_anna · 1445 days ago · 558 comments on HN

Article summary

The article announces the addition of three new books to the Pirate Library Mirror, a digital library that hosts copyrighted content without permission. The blog post itself does not host or link to copyrighted files, but rather provides information on how to access the library. The author of the blog emphasizes that they only host their own words. The discussion revolves around the ethics of sharing copyrighted content and the role of libraries in providing access to knowledge.

Main themes

  • copyright and piracy
  • libraries and access to knowledge
  • author compensation
  • digital lending and e-books
  • first sale doctrine
  • consumer rights

What commenters say

  • Some argue that authors should be compensated for their work when it is shared through libraries or online platforms.
  • Others believe that knowledge should be free and accessible to everyone, regardless of the author's compensation.
  • The concept of first sale doctrine is cited as a precedent for libraries lending books without paying additional fees to authors or publishers.
  • The rise of e-books and digital lending has created new challenges and complexities in the way libraries acquire and lend materials.
  • Some propose that libraries should pay a fee to authors or publishers each time a book is lent out, while others argue that this would undermine consumer rights.
  • The difference between physical and digital lending is highlighted, with some arguing that e-books enable concurrent access by hundreds of thousands of people, which is not possible with physical books.
  • The role of libraries in providing access to knowledge is seen as essential, but the question of how to compensate authors and publishers for their work remains a point of contention.